4th November 2003
20-Year Homebirth
Battle Ends Tomorrow
in Supreme Court


Tomorrow will see the culmination of 20 years of consumer litigation, as the Supreme Court decides whether or not home birth is to remain an option for less well off women, or whether it will become a choice reserved solely for the rich.

Sociologist and health correspondent Marie O’Connor points out that the Government’s decision to push through the Hanly agenda will leave thousands of women around the country without access to maternity care: “If consultant bodies succeed in closing these maternity units, home birth will become a vital link in the delivery of local services. Women cannot be expected to drive for two hours in the height of labour”.

Home birth parents, grandparents, babies born at home and midwives will gather in the Round Hall and on the steps of the Four Courts to hear the verdict on an appeal taken by four home birth mothers in Dublin against the South-Western Area Health Board’s refusal to give them a home birth ‘grant’. At 10.30 a.m. tomorrow the issue of whether or not women are entitled to a free home birth service from the State under the 1970 Health Act will be decided.

The home birth issue has been hotly debated in recent years, particularly in Dublin. Parents making this choice see home as offering a safer environment for a baby to be born into, away from the dangers of “active [medical] management” in hospital, according to the Home Birth Association. “Women choosing home birth are putting safety first”, says Krysia Lynch-Rybaczuk, the Association’s PRO. “We look forward to seeing women’s right to a free home birth service from the State restored”.

Meanwhile the National Birth Alliance says that choice in childbirth is central to women’s human rights: “Consultant bodies propose to close 8 or 9 maternity units around the country, yet they refuse to allow midwives to run the services”, says Philomena Canning, an independent midwife in the Dublin area.

For further details, please call:

Home Birth Association
Krysia Lynch-Rybaczuk
Telephone: 01 660 3499
Mobile: 087 754 3751

Independent Midwife ERHA
Philomena Canning
Telephone: 01 495 1902
Mobile: 087 290 0017

National Birth Alliance
© Marie O’Connor
Telephone: 01 838 8168
Mobile: 087 918 2722


© National Birth Alliance
An Chomhghuallaiocht Naisiunta Breithe

4th November 2003
20-Year Homebirth Battle Ends Tomorrow in Supreme Court

Turf war reaches Supreme Court

22 September
Junk research slammed by ERHA Midwives

Truth or Fiction?: a review of a new medical "study" on home birth in Dublin

5 September 2003
Rolling back the Bonner and Kinder Reports

27 August 2003
The Hanley Report

20 August 2003
A system
without locks


14 May 2003
The pros and cons of Caesarean section

8 May 2003
Irish Midwife a vanishing species

27 March 2003
How the boys
Finally beat the girls


July 2003
Irish Medical Journal Original Paper





























If you arrive on this or any of Maternity Matters pages from a search engine please click on "HOME" to get site with full menu



Site developed and maintained by Kathy McMahon