1943 Florin - Fake

at 400 dots / inch


Irish Coinage


Back to Main Page

Detail Image

2003 - Copyright
Version 1.11
22nd June, 2003


This is a fake 1943 florin.

This is the most common type of fake of this coin. It has been made by filing the 1 from a 1941 florin and soldering on a 3 cut from a 1939 florin. The field around the 3 looks uneven under a glass and in good light the shadow of the 1 is just visible. I have seen 3 different examples of this type of fake in the past few years.

After the work was done on this coin it was darkened - typically with a sulpher compound - and subsequenly burnished to soften the detail and brighten up the raised surfaces again.

A few points worth noting:

- The burnishing was less intense in the area of the 3 leaving a larger darker area around it - this was done because the forger did not want to expose the uneveness in the field aroud the 3 by burnishing it excessively.

- The darkening process was very unnatural and reached into all the small nicks on the coin - after the burnishing these nicks are left unusually black such as all the black specks on the salmon. Darkeing such as from ground burial does not normally work into the tiny crevaces so thoroughly.

- The placement of the 3 is slightly too far from the 4 and is very slightly tilted (clockwise) compared to a real coin.

- The digit 3 has a couple of bumps around its edge (see inside the curve) where a tiny sliver of the original coin or a tiny bubble of solder was left by the forger.

In general people buy fakes when they are offered cheaply - I'm sure someone could get lucky, but most people who own 1943 florins have bought them from reputable dealers or in a public auction or from a collector they know and have paid a fair price for them. Most people who end up with fakes have usually bougtht them too quickly from someone they don't know (and may not be able to trace) because the price was low and they thought they were 'making a killing'.

'If it looks to good to be true - then it probably is too good to be true'.

You have been warned.


Hit your back button to return to the page you came from or select :