Contents
Electronic mail address: iitdweb@tinet.ie
Web address: http://homepage.tinet.ie/~iitdmw
|
IITD Mid West
Chapter
Book Reviews Page
Book Reviews
Books of interest to members are reviewed by members
and listed as follows:
Title |
|
Author(s) |
|
ISBN |
|
Publication details |
|
Brief description of the book |
|
Brief review |
|
Name of the reviewer. |
|
This page is initially listed alphabetically by title.
At a later stage, we will consider a search facility and
the use of keywords or content listings. If you wish to
become a reviewer, please send your review in the format
above to iitdweb@tinet.ie.
Books of interest to managers and trainers are reviewed here and listed as follows:
McGregor, Douglas The Human Side of Enterprise
Kohn, Alfie Punished by Rewards
Covey, Stephen R. The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
Furnham, Adrian The Psychology of Managerial Incompetence
Title: | The Human Side of Enterprise |
Author: | Douglas McGregor |
New York McGraw-Hill 1960 |
This classic of management
literature examines the assumptions about human
behaviour which underlie management action and defines two extremes of management style;
Theory X and Theory Y. Theory X is described as
the traditional, authoritarian method of
direction and control that focuses on the task in
hand and assumes workers have little interest in
work and must be motivated through fear, money
and close control. Theory Y, onthe other hand, is
a more humanistic view that describes workers as
humans with a natural interest in work,
achievement and responsiblity who are motivated
by goals, who enjoy working hard and who will
self-regulate their performance under the right
conditions. Although nearly 40 years old, it is
nevertheless still a useful starting point for
examining management philosophy. Many of the
concepts would now be widely accepted in
business, although Theory X is still alive and
well. McGregor puts Theory Y forward as a
universally desireable management approach that
will work effectively in all circumstances.
Managers would disagree and point to
circumstances and organisational contexts in
which Theory X is not only defensible, but the
only sensible way to manage.
Back to top
Title: | Punished by Rewards |
Author: | Alfie Kohn |
New York Houghton Mifflin 1993 |
Kohn has been arguing against the use of standard motivational tools, like money, for many years. This book, now available in paperback, is his most complete argument and challenges the whole foundation for using rewards as a means to motivate.
His main argument is that people motivate themselves and the provision of external rewards reduces their inherent motivation to carry out the task involved. Instead, the person becomes focused on acquiring the reward; completion of the task is merely instrumental. Kohn's description of the insidious nature of our behavioural assumptions is quite stunning, using the three contexts of work, school and child-rearing. In each case, he contends, the provision of external rewards (including praise) does not result in greater motivation, but reduces inherent interest in the task, replacing it with an interest in the reward.
This book is for any manager, trainer, teacher or parent who has grappled with the means of motivating others. As a contrarian view, it may help to explain why so many people remain unmotivated (or undermotivated) despite the best efforts of their bosses, teachers and parents.
Back to top
Title: | The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People |
Author: | Stephen R. Covey |
London Simon and Schuster 1992 |
This is one of those hugely fashionable books that has sold over a million. At one level it is a highly practical time management book with much sound, solid sense for making better use of your time. At another level it is a set of principles for living a good life. It is the sort of book, therefore, that could appeal to two very different audiences and yet manages to do so without alienating either.
If you are a hard nosed pragmatist, treat this book as containing some good techniques for time management. If, on the other hand, you are searching for a book to change your life, treat it as the possible answer to your search. Either way, the book is well organised and fairly well written, in a rather american sort of way. It is very conversational, with many examples to bolster and explain his arguments. It is probably worth reading by any manager who is not perfectly happy with his or her managment practice or with the lifelstyle s/he has ended up with. However, as usual, there is no such thing as a free lunch, and anyone trying to get the most from Covey's book is facing several years of effort.
Back to top
Title: | The Psychology of Managerial Incompetence |
Author: | Adrian Furnham |
London Whurr 1998 |
Amusing books by serious authors are something of a rarity. Furnham is undoubtedly a serious author, professors of psychology generally are. But in this book, subtitled A Sceptic's Dictionary of Modern Organisational Issues, he has managed to inform, entertain, challenge and occasionally amuse.
He starts by introducing the notion that the psychological attributes of managers has a direct bearing on their behaviour at work and that this behaviour, in turn, influences the style and culture of the organisation as a whole. All very reasonable so far but then he describes mangagers in terms of Paranoid, Compulsive, Dramatic, Depressive and Schizoid before debunking management myths, fashionable fads and the role of consultants.
The book then consists of a series of short essays in alphabetical sequence comprising expected topics like Appraisal, Benchmarking, Human Resources, Job Satisfaction and Teamwork and unexpected entries such as Hairiness, Job-ad Speak, Music while you Work and Punishing the Punctual. In every case Furnham is solid in his exposition of each topic and utterly fearless in exposing bunkum. He calls himself a sceptic and rightly so, but some of these essays border on the cynical.
If you enjoy thinking about management and have no fear of basic psychology, this book will provide you with hours of thought-provoking reading and the occasional chuckle.
Back to top
Please send me mail
telling me what you think about this page and how we
might improve it.
Copyright 1999 IITD
Last revised: 24 January 1999
|